A new curiosity-focused Sunday School is coming to Old Whalers’! Wonder Sunday kicks off Sunday, September 27, 2026, at 10am.

Children of all ages are invited to join us for a special first day filled with art activities, stories, games, and Sunday Sundaes!

For more information, please reach out to the church office at (631) 725-0894 or oldwhalers@optonline.net.

What Is Wonder Sunday?

Wonder Sunday continues throughout the school year on the second and fourth Sundays of each month.

Kids of all ages are invited to wonder, observe, and ask questions about the world around them—the visible and the invisible—and to look for the divine in the everyday. We believe faith begins not only with answers, but with wonder.

What Happens on a Wonder Sunday?

Children begin in the sanctuary with the congregation, where they participate in a Children’s Message and discover a surprise item from the Wonder Box.

Then it’s off to the Kids’ Room with Ms. Jen for more faith exploration. Each lesson includes hands-on experiences—such as art, songs, skits, or science experiments—connected to Bible stories and children’s literature.

And Wonder Sunday doesn’t end when the lesson or church service is over! Everyone is welcome to gather in the social hall for a delicious and enjoyable time of fellowship—and, of course, the best cup of coffee in Sag Harbor.

Beyond Wonder Sunday

There are lots of other fun things happening for kids at Old Whalers’ throughout the year, including: a Halloween Party, Craft Fair activities, a Christmas Pageant, Movie Nights, Palm Processions, and more!

At Old Whalers’, we understand how important a positive and active relationship with spirituality can be for children. We also believe in the importance of an active, loving community.

We hope your children will find Old Whalers’ to be a WONDER-ful place to learn, grow, ask questions, and experience life together.

FAQ

When does Wonder Sunday begin?

Our kickoff event is Sunday, September 27, 2026, at 10am.

When do Wonder Sundays take place?

Wonder Sunday meets on the second and fourth Sundays throughout the school year.

How long does Wonder Sunday last?

Approximately 10am–11:15am.

What ages is Wonder Sunday for?

Wonder Sunday is designed for children ages 3–11, but tweens and teens are also welcome to join us and help with lessons.

Can parents or caregivers join their children in the Kids’ Room?

Absolutely! If having a parent or caregiver nearby helps a child feel more comfortable, they are welcome to be accompanied by a familiar adult.

Is there a drop-off option?

At this time, we don’t have the staffing to support a drop-off program. A parent or caregiver must be present throughout Wonder Sunday. They may either stay in the sanctuary for the church service or join their child in the Kids’ Room.

Is there a fee to participate in Wonder Sunday?

No! Wonder Sunday is completely free. Some special events may have a small fee.

Who is the Wonder Sunday instructor?

Meet Jen DeVane-Mulhern, “Ms. Jen,” our Wonder Sunday instructor! Ms. Jen has a BFA in Art Education and many years of experience teaching art and children’s dance. She is also entering her third year teaching religious education at Old Whalers’ Church.

For more information, please call the church office at 631-725-0894 or email us at oldwhalers@optonline.net.