Applications Available to be part of our Craft Fair, Tree Lighting, Community Caroling, and Kid’s Activities-November 29th, 12 PM-6 PM Please apply prior to November 1st -Looking forward to seeing you there!

Apply to be part of our new Holiday Craft Fair-scheduled for November 29th from 12-6- Tree Lighting, Community Caroling in our beautiful sanctuary, Kid’s activities, and a local craft fair. Applications available-please apply soon!

https://mcusercontent.com/08caed21543e117da746335b0/files/84e6e8b4-de69-2621-f31c-8d51d6139058/Vendor_app.pdf

Kick Off the Holidays with Us!

Join us for a festive afternoon at our beautiful historic church! Enjoy Christmas shopping at our amazing Craft Fair from 12–6 PM, featuring unique gifts from local crafters. Warm up at our Hot Chocolate Bar, complete with sweet treats and Christmas cookies.

Bring the family for kids’ crafts, Christmas stories, and songs from 3–4 PM, followed by a giant Christmas Sing-Along in the Sanctuary at 4 PM. Then, gather with us as we light our spectacular Christmas Tree at 5 PM!

It’s fun for everyone—a celebration you won’t forget and a wonderful way to support our local makers. We can’t wait to see you there!

A Community Thanksgiving Celebration
Thursday, November 20, 2025 • 7 PM
Old Whalers’ Church, Sag Harbor

Join us for a very special community service as local ministers from diverse faith traditions come together in a spirit of gratitude and unity. Through song, prayer, storytelling, and reflection, we will celebrate the many blessings that connect us all.

An offertory collection will be taken during the service to support the Sag Harbor and Bridgehampton Food Pantries, helping to nourish our neighbors in need.

After the service, stay for a Pie Extravaganza—a delicious time of fellowship, dessert, and heartfelt conversation.

All are welcome. Let’s give thanks together!

On November 2nd we gather to honor and remember those in our community and church family who have passed away in the past year. During the service, we will light candles and ring a bell in tribute to their lives and legacies. This will be a meaningful time of reflection, gratitude, and hope as we celebrate the promise of eternal life. Please call the church office if you would like you loved one to be remembered 631-725-0894. Everyone welcome.

Join us for a Community Halloween Gathering at Old Whalers’ Church-bring a carved jack-o-lantern to help light up the night. There will be singing and dancing-snacks and a Halloween Parade through the sanctuary while our organist plays the famous Bach Tocatta and Fugue in Dm-Everyone is welcome for this ‘Spooktacular’ night of fun and community. We hope to see you there!

Our monthly Prayer Group Meeting will be a wonderful time of coffee, conversation, prayer, reflection and inspiration. Please join us for this lovely community gathering! Everyone is welcome! Join Us!

Dear Friends-

Now more than ever, families are searching for places where they feel truly welcome—a space where children and parents alike can grow, connect, and find joy together. At Old Whalers’ Church in Sag Harbor, we invite your family to be part of our vibrant community, where every Sunday is a celebration of togetherness and belonging.

Remember when Sundays were reserved for family and reflection? While times have shifted and our weekends have grown busy, we believe that church can still be an oasis—a place to slow down, reconnect, and build lasting memories with your loved ones and new friends.

We warmly invite you and your children to experience Sunday School in our beautiful, historic church. Our doors—and our hearts—are open to every family, and we can’t wait to welcome you. Here, Sunday School isn’t just about learning, it's about living our faith in fun and memorable ways - through laughter, creativity, and friendship. Children sing, play, make art, and discover what it means to be loved and to love in return—all while building bonds that last for years.

Research by Lisa Miller, author of The Spiritual Child, shows how children who grow up in spiritual communities are more resilient, compassionate, and confident—qualities that benefit them throughout life. Sunday School at Old Whalers’ is designed to help your children grow into their best selves, surrounded by caring adults and peers.

Whether you’re new to Sag Harbor or your family has deep roots here, you are welcome here. Every child is cherished, every parent is valued, and every family is celebrated. There’s a place for you in our circle.

Come join us Sunday, September 14th at 10 AM—bring your children, their friends, and your own curiosity. Discover a place where your family can thrive, make friends, and share in the joy of community and faith.

We look forward to seeing you!

With all good wishes,

Rev. Nancy Remkus

A wonderful morning of history, music, inspiration and community-please join us for any or all of our presentations-everyone is welcome and there will be a wonderful coffee hour! Come pray like an Old Whaler’!!

Join us for a morning of music, prayer and reflection! Everyone welcome!

Join us as we come together for special blessings -teachers, students and parents. Let’s sing some Morning Program songs together and prepare our hearts for a new school year! Everyone welcome! Please join us!

Please join the Sag Harbor community as we honor and recognize the work of our food pantry volunteers at a special Sunday service. A special reception will follow in our social hall. Everyone is encouraged and welcome to attend!

As our summer series begins to wind down we are so excited to welcome Singer/Songwriter/Teacher Chris Kline to join us offering two songs during our Sunday Service! Please join us-everyone welcome!

A leading climate scientist, Chris Gloninger will be our guest speaker Sunday, August 17th and share his expertise and perspectives with us.

PLEASE help support the work of Old Whalers’ Church in our community by attending a benefit concert featuring the amazing music of the HOODOO Loungers-out on our front lawn-Friday, August 15th from 6-8 PM- hotdogs and beverages will be available-$20 suggested donation. Fun, Dood and Dancing! We hope to see you there!

Local legend Brad Beyer shares two songs with Old Whalers’ during our Sunday Service-Everyone welcome-please join us!

This Sunday We are so excited to have Caroline Doctorow share two songs with us during our Sunday Service-Pete Seeger's "God's Counting on Me" and the hymn "How Can I Keep From Singing?". Caroline a well known singer/songwriter has been a champion of American Folk Music and has song extensively both locally and throughout the country. Please join us for this wonderful service! Everyone is welcome!

Old Whalers’ Church welcomes Sister Ann Marino as guest celebrant this Sunday-we are all so excited for her to share her wisdom and heart with all of us. Her sermon title will be “And Then We Pray”. Everyone is so excited to welcome Sister Ann back to Old Whalers. A wonderful coffee hour will follow. Everyone welcome! Please join us!

Inda Eaton will perform two songs during our Sunday Service-stick around for our Summer Picnic-fun, games and hotdogs!

Please join us for our Annual Strawberry Social- a wonderful community event, delicious Strawberry Shortcake and a great way to help support Old Whalers’ - the place where Sag Harbor gathers!

Old Whalers’ Summer Series kicks off with local musician Klyph Black who will share two songs at our 10 AM Sunday Service-Join us for an inspirational Sunday service and a wonderful coffee hour that follows-Everyone welcome-please join us!

Please join us for our Sunday Service paying tribute to those who have given their lives for our freedom.

Come celebrate Easter Sunday at beautiful Old Whalers’ Church! ‘He has risen, He has risen indeed’! A beautiful celebration of words and music followed by an Easter Egg Hunt on the front lawn. Please join your community on this day of hope and promise.

A Beautiful Good Friday Service reflecting on the ‘Seven Last Words of Jesus’. Readings, Reflections and Musical Responses. Rev. Nancy Remkus

Come celebrate Palm Sunday with Old Whalers’ Church- a beautiful, reverent service of words and music-kids singing-palms-followed by a lovely luncheon. Come experience the warmth of community at Old Whalers’ Church.

Bring your favorite cereal - which you will place into the box representing the team that you hope will win the Super Bowl-cereal is counted by our youth-predictions made- and then it will be donated to the Sag Harbor Community Food Pantry. After the service our coffee hour will highlight a cereal buffet along with one of the best cups of coffee in town! Everyone welcome!

Come in from the Cold for Old Whalers’ Church’s Annual Soup Benefit-Live Music-homemade soup-a wonderful community event! $10.00